Nonstop Flights 14% Cheaper Than Connecting For US Routes?

When planning your airfare, at some point you’ll probably come across connecting flights and will consider if the extra time connecting will be worth the price.

Will you save money by taking a less convenient flight with connections or will a nonstop flight be cheaper?

We analyzed over 600 data points from the three US legacy carriers in order to figure out if booking a connecting flight will actually save you money when flying around the US.

Let’s take a look at the findings!

Are connecting flights cheaper than nonstop flights?

We reviewed over 600 data points for the main US carriers: United, American, and Delta, and we found that connecting flights in 2023 were on average 14% more expensive than nonstop flights.

Tip: Use the free app WalletFlo to help you travel the world for free by finding the best travel credit cards and promotions!

Price breakdown by airline

The price increase between the major US carriers ranged from about 10% to 20% when it came to connecting vs nonstop domestic flights.

Here are the figures we got for each airline:

American Airlines

For American Airlines domestic flights, we found that connecting flights were 19% more expensive than nonstop flights. This came out to a $57 difference.

Delta Air Lines

For Delta Air Lines domestic flights, we found that connecting flights were 15% more expensive than nonstop flights. This came out to an $89 difference.

United Airlines

For United Airlines domestic flights, we found that connecting flights were 9% more expensive than nonstop flights. This came out to a $49 difference.

Note: While connecting flights were more expensive on average, sometimes the connecting flights were cheaper.

Other considerations

Besides price, here are some other things you want to consider when choosing a nonstop vs connecting flight.

Risk of delays

When you add on a connection to your itinerary you are adding on the risk of an additional delay or cancellation affecting your travel plans.

I really try to avoid connecting flights if it means connecting through a place like Chicago (ORD) in the winter, because I’m well aware of the risks of weather throwing a wrench in my plans.

If you’re connecting flights are all on the same itinerary then the airline responsible for the delay should help you out and they may do so in various ways.

But I would highly discourage you from booking connecting flights on separate itineraries unless you absolutely have to do that and you can give yourself plenty of time to deal with delays.

If you are connecting on the same itinerary, you can cut things closer without the risk of losing out on your money.

The amount of time you’ll need for the connection will vary based on the connecting airport, but you can often get by with something like a one hour layover.

Airport expenses

Depending on how long your layover is, you may have to kill some time at the airport as you wait for your connecting flight. This means more temptations to spend money at over priced airport restaurants, shops, and bars.

Personally, I’m a big fan of airport lounge access for this reason.

Between Priority Pass and Centurion Lounges, we can pretty much always find a place to kill some time during a layover and the cost of the membership is built into our credit card annual fees.

Related: 19 Ideas on What To Do When Bored at the Airport

Lost luggage

Every time you make a connection, your luggage also has to make a connection.

This means that you increase the odds of luggage getting lost each time you connect. When your luggage is lost or delayed, it’s almost always eventually found but it can be a pretty stressful experience to deal with that.

Tip: It’s a good idea to have baggage delay insurance so that you can go out and buy necessities while you wait for your luggage and then get reimbursed for those expenses.

More miles/segments for elite status

A connecting flight could earn you more miles and segments than a nonstop flight. So for some people chasing elite status, booking a connection could make more sense.

Data points

At UponArriving, we always believe in transparency with our data and so if you’d like to take a look at some of the real-world prices we found for these flights, you can find them below.

The prices reflect prices falling in the same or similar fare bucket.

For the most part, we attempted to take prices for discounted fares so it’s possible that the coonclusions could be skewed towards cheaper tickets rather than the full fare tickets.

Also, most of these connecting flights were true connecting flights and not direct flights.

A direct flight could be a connecting flight that does not change flight numbers and these appear to be much more rare to find than connecting flights.

Delta

RoutesClassNonstop1 Stop
Atlanta (ATL) to Portland (PDX)Economy$349$358
Atlanta (ATL) to Portland (PDX)Comfort+$539$548
Atlanta (ATL) to Portland (PDX)First$829$838
Atlanta (ATL) to Las Vegas (LAS)Economy$329$642
Atlanta (ATL) to Las Vegas (LAS)Comfort+$569$862
Atlanta (ATL) to Las Vegas (LAS)First$859$1,152
Atlanta (ATL) to San Francisco (SFO)Economy$429$559
Atlanta (ATL) to San Francisco (SFO)Comfort+$659$829
Atlanta (ATL) to San Francisco (SFO)First$959$1,539
Atlanta (ATL) to Denver (DEN)Economy$259$522
Atlanta (ATL) to Denver (DEN)Comfort+$449$772
Atlanta (ATL) to Denver (DEN)First$669$1,132
Atlanta (ATL) to Chicago (ORD)Economy$171$180
Atlanta (ATL) to Chicago (ORD)Comfort+$211$220
Atlanta (ATL) to Chicago (ORD)First$321$330
Atlanta (ATL) to Phoenix (PHX)Economy$319$572
Atlanta (ATL) to Phoenix (PHX)Comfort+$559$732
Atlanta (ATL) to Phoenix (PHX)First$849$942
Atlanta (ATL) to Miami (MIA)Economy$239$442
Atlanta (ATL) to Miami (MIA)Comfort+$329$522
Atlanta (ATL) to Miami (MIA)First$489$682
Boston (BOS) to Seattle (SEA)Economy$299$308
Boston (BOS) to Seattle (SEA)Comfort+$459$468
Boston (BOS) to Seattle (SEA)First$939$948
Boston (BOS) to Las Vegas (LAS)Economy$339$348
Boston (BOS) to Las Vegas (LAS)Comfort+$569$578
Boston (BOS) to Las Vegas (LAS)First$769$778
Boston (BOS) to Denver (DEN)Economy$289$298
Boston (BOS) to Denver (DEN)Comfort+$419$428
Boston (BOS) to Denver (DEN)First$619$628
Boston (BOS) to Chicago (ORD)Economy$177$186
Boston (BOS) to Chicago (ORD)Comfort+$217$226
Boston (BOS) to Chicago (ORD)First$297$306
Boston (BOS) to Dallas (DFW)Economy$239$248
Boston (BOS) to Dallas (DFW)Comfort+$329$338
Boston (BOS) to Dallas (DFW)First$479$488
Boston (BOS) to Minneapolis−Saint Paul (MSP)Economy$329$652
Boston (BOS) to Minneapolis−Saint Paul (MSP)Comfort+$489$792
Boston (BOS) to Minneapolis−Saint Paul (MSP)First$719$1,122
Boston (BOS) to Cincinnati (CVG)Economy$219$228
Boston (BOS) to Cincinnati (CVG)Comfort+$309$318
Boston (BOS) to Cincinnati (CVG)First$419$428
New York (JFK) to Seattle (SEA)Economy$329$338
New York (JFK) to Seattle (SEA)Comfort+$449$458
New York (JFK) to Seattle (SEA)First$969$978
New York (JFK) to Orlando (MCO)Economy$279$552
New York (JFK) to Orlando (MCO)Comfort+$369$622
New York (JFK) to Orlando (MCO)First$539$742
New York (JFK) to Fort Lauderdale (FLL)Economy$309$318
New York (JFK) to Fort Lauderdale (FLL)Comfort+$399$408
New York (JFK) to Fort Lauderdale (FLL)First$609$693
New York (JFK) to San Diego (SAN)Economy$309$318
New York (JFK) to San Diego (SAN)Comfort+$469$478
New York (JFK) to San Diego (SAN)First$1,084$1,018
New York (JFK) to Nashville (BNA)Economy$199$208
New York (JFK) to Nashville (BNA)Comfort+$239$248
New York (JFK) to Nashville (BNA)First$289$298
New York (JFK) to Austin (AUS)Economy$299$308
New York (JFK) to Austin (AUS)Comfort+$389$398
New York (JFK) to Austin (AUS)First$979$1,063
New York (JFK) to Las Vegas (LAS)Economy$309$318
New York (JFK) to Las Vegas (LAS)Comfort+$439$448
New York (JFK) to Las Vegas (LAS)First$789$798
Los Angeles (LAX) to Portland (PDX)Economy$189$452
Los Angeles (LAX) to Portland (PDX)Comfort+$229$542
Los Angeles (LAX) to Portland (PDX)First$289$732
Los Angeles (LAX) to Denver (DEN)Economy$149$168
Los Angeles (LAX) to Denver (DEN)Comfort+$189$208
Los Angeles (LAX) to Denver (DEN)First$249$268
Los Angeles (LAX) to Minneapolis−Saint Paul (MSP)Economy$299$572
Los Angeles (LAX) to Minneapolis−Saint Paul (MSP)Comfort+$429$702
Los Angeles (LAX) to Minneapolis−Saint Paul (MSP)First$629$952
Los Angeles (LAX) to Detroit (DTW)Economy$459$602
Los Angeles (LAX) to Detroit (DTW)Comfort+$699$772
Los Angeles (LAX) to Detroit (DTW)First$1,039$1,052
Los Angeles (LAX) to Fort Lauderdale (FLL)Economy$279$288
Los Angeles (LAX) to Fort Lauderdale (FLL)Comfort+$399$408
Los Angeles (LAX) to Fort Lauderdale (FLL)First$1,009$1,018
Los Angeles (LAX) to Nashville (BNA)Economy$479$488
Los Angeles (LAX) to Nashville (BNA)Comfort+$619$628
Los Angeles (LAX) to Nashville (BNA)First$1,059$1,068
Los Angeles (LAX) to New Orleans (MSY)Economy$429$438
Los Angeles (LAX) to New Orleans (MSY)Comfort+$539$548
Los Angeles (LAX) to New Orleans (MSY)First$1,550$1,559
Salt Lake City (SLC) to Portland (PDX)Economy$149$352
Salt Lake City (SLC) to Portland (PDX)Comfort+$189$422
Salt Lake City (SLC) to Portland (PDX)First$269$572
Salt Lake City (SLC) to New York (EWR)Economy$319$328
Salt Lake City (SLC) to New York (EWR)Comfort+$479$488
Salt Lake City (SLC) to New York (EWR)First$789$818
Salt Lake City (SLC) to Washington (DCA)Economy$399$408
Salt Lake City (SLC) to Washington (DCA)Comfort+$539$548
Salt Lake City (SLC) to Washington (DCA)First$749$758
Salt Lake City (SLC) to Austin (AUS)Economy$299$308
Salt Lake City (SLC) to Austin (AUS)Comfort+$389$398
Salt Lake City (SLC) to Austin (AUS)First$559$568
Salt Lake City (SLC) to Chicago (ORD)Economy$339$348
Salt Lake City (SLC) to Chicago (ORD)Comfort+$409$418
Salt Lake City (SLC) to Chicago (ORD)First$539$548
Salt Lake City (SLC) to Kansas City (MCI)Economy$249$258
Salt Lake City (SLC) to Kansas City (MCI)Comfort+$319$328
Salt Lake City (SLC) to Kansas City (MCI)First$459$468
Salt Lake City (SLC) to Miami (MIA)Economy$319$328
Salt Lake City (SLC) to Miami (MIA)Comfort+$459$468
Salt Lake City (SLC) to Miami (MIA)First$689$698

American

RoutesClassNonstop1 Stop
Dallas (DFW) to Philadelphia (PHL)Economy$299$307
Dallas (DFW) to Philadelphia (PHL)First$674$682
Dallas (DFW) to Seattle (SEA)Economy$212$221
Dallas (DFW) to Seattle (SEA)First$935$944
Dallas (DFW) to Las Vegas (LAS)Economy$269$278
Dallas (DFW) to Las Vegas (LAS)First$573$582
Dallas (DFW) to Miami (MIA)Economy$245$253
Dallas (DFW) to Miami (MIA)First$537$545
Dallas (DFW) to New York (LGA)Economy$152$161
Dallas (DFW) to New York (LGA)First$610$619
Dallas (DFW) to Atlanta (ATL)Economy$262$270
Dallas (DFW) to Atlanta (ATL)First$461$469
Dallas (DFW) to Phoenix (PHX)Economy$213$222
Dallas (DFW) to Phoenix (PHX)First$447$456
Dallas (DFW) to Washington (DCA)Economy$223$231
Dallas (DFW) to Washington (DCA)First$402$410
Dallas (DFW) to St. Louis (STL)Economy$161$424
Dallas (DFW) to St. Louis (STL)First$360$850
Dallas (DFW) to Denver (DEN)Economy$149$497
Dallas (DFW) to Denver (DEN)First$308$968
Los Angeles (LAX) to Seattle (SEA)Economy$159$198
Los Angeles (LAX) to Seattle (SEA)First$358$397
Los Angeles (LAX) to Atlanta (ATL)Economy$219$228
Los Angeles (LAX) to Atlanta (ATL)First$608$617
Los Angeles (LAX) to Houston (IAH)Economy$209$218
Los Angeles (LAX) to Houston (IAH)First$508$517
Los Angeles (LAX) to Orlando (MCO)Economy$239$247
Los Angeles (LAX) to Orlando (MCO)First$714$722
Los Angeles (LAX) to Denver (DEN)Economy$119$340
Los Angeles (LAX) to Denver (DEN)First$269$657
Los Angeles (LAX) to Tucson (TUS)Economy$159$168
Los Angeles (LAX) to Tucson (TUS)First$229$238
Los Angeles (LAX) to St. Louis (STL)Economy$236$244
Los Angeles (LAX) to St. Louis (STL)First$678$686
Los Angeles (LAX) to Boston (BOS)Economy$275$231
Los Angeles (LAX) to Boston (BOS)First$969$1,097
Los Angeles (LAX) to San Francisco (SFO)Economy$149$238
Los Angeles (LAX) to San Francisco (SFO)First$219$457
Los Angeles (LAX) to Indianapolis (IND)Economy$239$278
Los Angeles (LAX) to Indianapolis (IND)First$514$553
New York (JFK) to San Francisco (SFO)Economy$274$283
New York (JFK) to San Francisco (SFO)First$1,119$1,159
New York (JFK) to Miami (MIA)Economy$164$428
New York (JFK) to Miami (MIA)First$735$827
New York (JFK) to Austin (AUS)Economy$209$289
New York (JFK) to Austin (AUS)First$598$578
New York (JFK) to Boston (BOS)Economy$144$323
New York (JFK) to Boston (BOS)First$379$453
New York (JFK) to Phoenix (PHX)Economy$189$394
New York (JFK) to Phoenix (PHX)First$683$960
New York (JFK) to Washington (DCA)Economy$179$313
New York (JFK) to Washington (DCA)First$229$483
New York (JFK) to Charlotte (CLT)Economy$209$218
New York (JFK) to Charlotte (CLT)First$348$357
New York (JFK) to Nashville (BNA)Economy$149$192
New York (JFK) to Nashville (BNA)First$239$282
New York (JFK) to Indianapolis (IND)Economy$239$248
New York (JFK) to Indianapolis (IND)First$438$447
New York (JFK) to Chicago (ORD)Economy$213$188
New York (JFK) to Chicago (ORD)First$412$387
Charlotte (CLT) to Portland (PDX)Economy$401$410
Charlotte (CLT) to Portland (PDX)First$845$854
Charlotte (CLT) to New York (LGA)Economy$208$217
Charlotte (CLT) to New York (LGA)First$347$356
Charlotte (CLT) to Miami (MIA)Economy$283$292
Charlotte (CLT) to Miami (MIA)First$482$491
Charlotte (CLT) to New Orleans (MSY)Economy$303$312
Charlotte (CLT) to New Orleans (MSY)First$502$511
Charlotte (CLT) to San Diego (SAN)Economy$401$410
Charlotte (CLT) to San Diego (SAN)First$845$854
Charlotte (CLT) to Las Vegas (LAS)Economy$365$374
Charlotte (CLT) to Las Vegas (LAS)First$799$808
Charlotte (CLT) to St. Louis (STL)Economy$160$169
Charlotte (CLT) to St. Louis (STL)First$359$368
Charlotte (CLT) to Salt Lake City (SLC)Economy$248$307
Charlotte (CLT) to Salt Lake City (SLC)First$718$727
Charlotte (CLT) to Minneapolis (MSP)Economy$238$247
Charlotte (CLT) to Minneapolis (MSP)First$328$337
Charlotte (CLT) to Phoenix (PHX)Economy$365$374
Charlotte (CLT) to Phoenix (PHX)First$754$763
Chicago (ORD) to Portland (PDX)Economy$239$452
Chicago (ORD) to Portland (PDX)First$628$906
Chicago (ORD) to Houston (IAH)Economy$236$222
Chicago (ORD) to Houston (IAH)First$485$471
Chicago (ORD) to Miami (MIA)Economy$223$232
Chicago (ORD) to Miami (MIA)First$472$481
Chicago (ORD) to Washington (DCA)Economy$179$188
Chicago (ORD) to Washington (DCA)First$505$514
Chicago (ORD) to Tucson (TUS)Economy$245$254
Chicago (ORD) to Tucson (TUS)First$721$730
Chicago (ORD) to San Francisco (SFO)Economy$241$249
Chicago (ORD) to San Francisco (SFO)First$696$704
Chicago (ORD) to Albuquerque (ABQ)Economy$215$224
Chicago (ORD) to Albuquerque (ABQ)First$464$473
Chicago (ORD) to Atlanta (ATL)Economy$191$200
Chicago (ORD) to Atlanta (ATL)First$291$300
Chicago (ORD) to Denver (DEN)Economy$213$222
Chicago (ORD) to Denver (DEN)First$372$381
Chicago (ORD) to Nashville (BNA)Economy$170$179
Chicago (ORD) to Nashville (BNA)First$350$359

United

RoutesClassNonstop1 Stop
New York (EWR) to Los Angeles (LAX)Economy$199$253
New York (EWR) to Los Angeles (LAX)First$749$925
New York (EWR) to Chicago (ORD)Economy$106$115
New York (EWR) to Chicago (ORD)First$588$597
New York (EWR) to Dallas (DFW)Economy$119$223
New York (EWR) to Dallas (DFW)First$848$857
New York (EWR) to Boston (BOS)Economy$114$123
New York (EWR) to Boston (BOS)First$468$477
New York (EWR) to Miami (MIA)Economy$190$138
New York (EWR) to Miami (MIA)First$778$1,267
New York (EWR) to Portland (PDX)Economy$334$408
New York (EWR) to Portland (PDX)First$1,028$1,507
New York (EWR) to Minneapolis (MSP)Economy$169$178
New York (EWR) to Minneapolis (MSP)First$478$377
New York (EWR) to Salt Lake City (SLC)Economy$239$248
New York (EWR) to Salt Lake City (SLC)First$948$957
New York (EWR) to Phoenix (PHX)Economy$289$422
New York (EWR) to Phoenix (PHX)First$1,008$1,017
New York (EWR) to San Diego (SAN)Economy$339$468
New York (EWR) to San Diego (SAN)First$1,028$1,037
San Francisco (SFO) to Las Vegas (LAS)Economy$124$154
San Francisco (SFO) to Las Vegas (LAS)First$468$477
San Francisco (SFO) to Chicago (ORD)Economy$291$345
San Francisco (SFO) to Chicago (ORD)First$1,448$1,457
San Francisco (SFO) to Dallas (DFW)Economy$194$238
San Francisco (SFO) to Dallas (DFW)First$858$867
San Francisco (SFO) to Boston (BOS)Economy$359$368
San Francisco (SFO) to Boston (BOS)First$1,498$1,507
San Francisco (SFO) to Minneapolis (MSP)Economy$299$301
San Francisco (SFO) to Minneapolis (MSP)First$898$1,457
San Francisco (SFO) to Orlando (MCO)Economy$361$365
San Francisco (SFO) to Orlando (MCO)First$1,498$1,507
San Francisco (SFO) to New Orleans (MSY)Economy$419$378
San Francisco (SFO) to New Orleans (MSY)First$1,448$1,457
San Francisco (SFO) to Kansas City (MCI)Economy$235$244
San Francisco (SFO) to Kansas City (MCI)First$642$640
San Francisco (SFO) to Albuquerque (ABQ)Economy$275$352
San Francisco (SFO) to Albuquerque (ABQ)First$658$1,107
San Francisco (SFO) to Denver (DEN)Economy$289$298
San Francisco (SFO) to Denver (DEN)First$1,148$1,157
Houston (IAH) to Charlotte (CLT)Economy$264$248
Houston (IAH) to Charlotte (CLT)First$463$447
Houston (IAH) to Boston (BOS)Economy$269$183
Houston (IAH) to Boston (BOS)First$658$641
Houston (IAH) to New York (EWR)Economy$164$148
Houston (IAH) to New York (EWR)First$558$597
Houston (IAH) to Washington (IAD)Economy$203$212
Houston (IAH) to Washington (IAD)First$565$574
Houston (IAH) to Philadelphia (PHL)Economy$229$218
Houston (IAH) to Philadelphia (PHL)First$547$467
Houston (IAH) to Seattle (SEA)Economy$209$218
Houston (IAH) to Seattle (SEA)First$658$667
Houston (IAH) to Las Vegas (LAS)Economy$203$294
Houston (IAH) to Las Vegas (LAS)First$838$847
Houston (IAH) to Phoenix (PHX)Economy$203$212
Houston (IAH) to Phoenix (PHX)First$736$745
Houston (IAH) to Kansas City (MCI)Economy$289$298
Houston (IAH) to Kansas City (MCI)First$438$447
Houston (IAH) to Los Angeles (LAX)Economy$259$268
Houston (IAH) to Los Angeles (LAX)First$848$857
Washington (IAD) to Los Angeles (LAX)Economy$183$248
Washington (IAD) to Los Angeles (LAX)First$1,018$1,027
Washington (IAD) to Chicago (ORD)Economy$159$180
Washington (IAD) to Chicago (ORD)First$548$557
Washington (IAD) to San Diego (SAN)Economy$339$341
Washington (IAD) to San Diego (SAN)First$1,018$1,027
Washington (IAD) to Portland (PDX)Economy$339$348
Washington (IAD) to Portland (PDX)First$998$1,007
Washington (IAD) to Phoenix (PHX)Economy$335$278
Washington (IAD) to Phoenix (PHX)First$948$957
Washington (IAD) to Miami (MIA)Economy$182$206
Washington (IAD) to Miami (MIA)First$1,148$1,157
Washington (IAD) to San Antonio (SAT)Economy$225$234
Washington (IAD) to San Antonio (SAT)First$588$579
Washington (IAD) to New Orleans (MSY)Economy$260$328
Washington (IAD) to New Orleans (MSY)First$738$1,157
Washington (IAD) to Cleveland (CLE)Economy$169$148
Washington (IAD) to Cleveland (CLE)First$748$447
Washington (IAD) to Detroit (DTW)Economy$139$133
Washington (IAD) to Detroit (DTW)First$238$232
Denver (DEN) to Chicago (ORD)Economy$279$338
Denver (DEN) to Chicago (ORD)First$1,098$1,107
Denver (DEN) to San Antonio (SAT)Economy$209$218
Denver (DEN) to San Antonio (SAT)First$618$1,107
Denver (DEN) to San Diego (SAN)Economy$219$228
Denver (DEN) to San Diego (SAN)First$638$647
Denver (DEN) to Portland (PDX)Economy$169$128
Denver (DEN) to Portland (PDX)First$459$468
Denver (DEN) to Boston (BOS)Economy$319$328
Denver (DEN) to Boston (BOS)First$928$1,457
Denver (DEN) to Miami (MIA)Economy$195$251
Denver (DEN) to Miami (MIA)First$928$1,457
Denver (DEN) to Nashville (BNA)Economy$249$258
Denver (DEN) to Nashville (BNA)First$748$757
Denver (DEN) to Detroit (DTW)Economy$298$307
Denver (DEN) to Detroit (DTW)First$778$787
Denver (DEN) to Las Vegas (LAS)Economy$144$183
Denver (DEN) to Las Vegas (LAS)First$558$567
Denver (DEN) to New Orleans (MSY)Economy$286$295
Denver (DEN) to New Orleans (MSY)First$768$777

Final word

If you’re wanting to fly with one of the main US airlines around the country, based on our data it appears that connecting flights will be more expensive on average.

This does not always hold true for international flights where connecting to a different city can bring down the price. We intend to introduce more data for more airlines in the near future and provide an even more comprehensive view of flight pricing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *